The Employer's Playbook: A Deep Dive into Avoiding Right to Work Civil Penalties in UK
For any UK business that employs staff, compliance with "Prevention of Illegal Working" legislation is a mission-critical function. A single mistake—hiring someone who does not have the right to work in the UK—can trigger a cascade of devastating consequences, starting with a fine of up to £60,000 per individual. These are not minor infractions; they are some of the most severe Civil Penalties in UK, designed to be a powerful deterrent.
The key to protecting your business is not just to hope for the best, but to implement a robust, unbreachable system of checks and record-keeping. The law provides a powerful shield for diligent employers, known as a "statutory excuse." This guide is a deep dive for employers, explaining exactly how to establish and maintain this legal defence. At Immigration Solicitors4me, our corporate immigration team are specialists in this area, providing audits, training, and robust legal defence to protect UK businesses from these significant risks.
What Exactly is an Employer's Legal Duty?
Under the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006, every UK employer has a legal duty to prevent illegal working. You must verify that every single person you employ, regardless of their nationality or ethnicity, has the right to perform the work you are offering them before their employment begins. Failing to do so is what exposes your business to the risk of Civil Penalties in UK.
The Manual Check: A Three-Step Process You Must Master
For employees who can provide physical documents (such as a British passport), the traditional manual check is a vital process. To establish a statutory excuse, you must perfectly execute all three steps:
- OBTAIN:You must be in possession of the employee's original, valid documents from the Home Office's approved lists. Photocopies or scans are not acceptable at this stage.
- CHECK:You must check the documents carefully for authenticity in the presence of the holder (either physically or via a live video link). You must be satisfied that they are genuine and belong to the person presenting them.
- COPY:You must take a clear copy of the relevant pages of the document, store it securely (digitally or physically), and record the date the check was carried out. This creates your evidence file.
The Digital Revolution: Using the Home Office Online Service
Increasingly, an individual's immigration status is purely digital. For many migrant workers holding a Biometric Residence Permit (BRP) or status under the EU Settlement Scheme, the only valid way to check their right to work is via the Home Office's online service.
How does it work? The prospective employee uses the "Prove your right to work" service on the GOV.UK website. This generates a nine-digit "share code" which they give to you, along with their date of birth. You then use this share code on the "View a job applicant's right to work details" page to see their official, real-time immigration status and any work restrictions. You must save a PDF or printout of this check to complete your statutory excuse.
List A vs. List B: Do You Know the Critical Difference?
The Home Office's approved document lists are split into two crucial categories:
- List A:These documents prove an ongoing, unlimited right to work (e.g., a British passport or a certificate of Indefinite Leave to Remain). A single, correct check at the start of employment provides you with a continuous statutory excuse for the entire duration of that person's employment.
- List B:These documents prove a time-limited right to work (e.g., a Skilled Worker visa). A check on a List B document provides you with a statutory excuse only up until the expiry date of the visa. It is a critical legal duty for you to conduct a follow-up check before the current visa expires. Failure to do so can result in Civil Penalties in UK if the employee has not extended their leave.
The Consequence Cascade: What Happens When a Check is Missed?
If the Home Office discovers you are employing someone without the right to work and you cannot produce evidence of a correct check, the consequences are severe and multi-layered.
- The Penalty Notice:You will receive a notice detailing the fine, which can be tens of thousands of pounds.
- Reputational Damage:Your business's name may be published by the government in a public list of non-compliant employers.
- Sponsor Licence Impact:If you hold a licence to sponsor skilled workers, this compliance failure will almost certainly lead to it being suspended or revoked, a catastrophic outcome.
Immigration Solicitors4me: Your Corporate Compliance Partner
Robust, consistent Right to Work checks are one of the most important HR functions in any UK business. At Immigration Solicitors4me, we are experts in helping businesses get this right. We provide:
- System Audits:A full review of your current processes to identify and fix any weaknesses.
- Staff Training:Bespoke training for your HR team on how to conduct compliant checks.
- Defence Against Penalties:Expert legal representation to challenge any unfairly issued Civil Penalties in UK.
Protect your business from the severe financial and reputational risks of non-compliance. To ensure your Right to Work systems are watertight, contact the corporate immigration specialists at Immigration Solicitors4me today.
English
Arabic
Français
Español
Português
Deutsch
Türkçe
Dutch
Italiano
Russian